SeriesStack

Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries Books in Order

by Danielle GarrettMystery, Thriller & Suspense

9 books so far (book 10 is due October 20, 2026). They run from Sprinkles and Sea Serpents (2021) to Batter and Broomsticks (2026). Rated 4.6 across 5,638 listener reviews.

Next Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries book

Whipped Cream and Werewolves

Book 10 · out October 20, 2026 · preorder now

Kindle Paperback Audiobook

Reading order

  1. Sprinkles and Sea Serpents

    Book 1 2021 4.5 (1.8k)

    They say you can't go home again...oh, if only that were true. Thanks to a series of unfortunate events - and one backstabbing frenemy - home is exactly where I'm headed.

    Kindle Paperback Audiobook

  2. Grimoires and Gingerbread

    Book 2 2021 4.4 (868)

    Christmas in Winterspell means ice skating, hot cocoa by the barrel, and frosted gingerbread houses. I was almost looking forward to it.

    Kindle Paperback Audiobook

  3. Mermaids and Meringue

    Book 3 2021 4.7 (922)

    It's a new year in Winterspell...and a new mystery. I've always wanted to meet a mermaid, but when I finally get my chance on New Year's Eve, the circumstances are far darker than I'd imagined.

    Kindle Paperback Audiobook

  4. Sugar Cookies and Sirens

    Book 4 2022 4.6 (642)

    The witch who can talk to animals meets the witch with a talking cat. What could go wrong? It's Valentine's Day in Winterspell, but not everyone appears to be feeling the love. And no, I'm not talking about my dateless self.

    Kindle Paperback Audiobook

  5. Hexes and Honey Buns

    Book 5 2022 4.8 (406)

    The pen is mightier than the sword - but what's a witch to do when she has writer's block? After landing my first official journalist job I thought the ideas would be spilling out faster than I could type.

    Kindle Paperback Audiobook

  6. Leprechauns and Lemon Bars

    Book 6 2023 4.6 (413)

    Shamrocks, rainbows, pots of gold, and . . . one irate leprechaun. Spring has sprung, and I'm finally getting out of town with my monster-hunting boyfriend.

    Kindle Paperback Audiobook

  7. Frosting and Fairies

    Book 7 2025 4.8 (302)

    A romance book festival comes to Winterspell, but not everyone is feeling the love. Small-town journalism isn't exactly a thrill ride. Between PTA meetings and bake sale bulletins, I was drowning in monotony.

    Kindle Paperback Audiobook

  8. Candy Apples and Clairvoyants

    Book 8 2025 4.6 (306)

    The Ghost of Halloween Past heads to Winterspell in this time-traveling tale of a bygone spooky season. High school senior Rosella Midnight heads to the town Harvest Party hoping to score a free candy bar and avoid her overachieving…

    Kindle Paperback Audiobook

  9. Batter and Broomsticks

    Book 9 2026 4.8 (6)

    Nothing says "small-town journalism" like stumbling over a corpse. The magic from the amplification stones is gone, and we have no idea where to find it, but by a stroke of luck, we meet a fairy who might.

    Kindle Paperback Audiobook

  10. Whipped Cream and Werewolves

    Book 10 Out October 20, 2026

    One missing person is a mystery. Five in a single night? That's a crisis. We're closer than ever to finding the culprit behind the magic theft, but it's hard to solve a case when your key researcher vanishes into thin air.

    Kindle Paperback Audiobook

Collections and companions

About this reading order

Books are listed in the series' own numbering, which for Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries is also the best order to read them in. Years are first publication where we could confirm it, and otherwise the first audiobook release.

If you like Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries